Research Research Area
FACT Stream · Research Area · 2014–2020

Design & Implementation
of User Fees

Municipal governments rely on user fees to fund services, yet fee design is rarely straightforward. This research examines the legal, equity, and fiscal dimensions of user fee design and implementation in Canadian municipalities — from case law constraints and western Canadian practice to the broader question of who pays for city services and why.

The Problem

User fees are an attractive tool for municipal finance — they connect service costs to service users and can reduce reliance on property taxes. But their design is constrained by Canadian case law, their distributional effects can be regressive, and their implementation varies widely across jurisdictions. Getting fee design right requires understanding the legal limits of what municipalities can charge, who bears the burden, and how fees interact with the broader fiscal structure of the city.

The Research

This research program spans over a decade of work on municipal user fees in Canada — from a comprehensive design and implementation guide published by the Canadian Tax Foundation, to edited volumes bringing together national expertise on municipal taxation and finance, to analysis of how western Canadian municipalities have used fees in practice. It also includes applied engagement through the City of Calgary Financial Task Force, translating research into policy-relevant recommendations for one of Canada's largest cities.

Books

📗
User Fees in Canada: A Municipal Design and Implementation Guide
Catherine Althaus and Lindsay M. Tedds · Canadian Tax Foundation · Toronto · 2016
FACT Canada
📗
Funding the Canadian City: A National Dialogue on Municipal Taxation and Fees
Lisa Phillips, Enid Slack and Lindsay M. Tedds (Eds.) · Canadian Tax Foundation · Toronto · 2019
FACT Canada

Book Chapters

📖
Who Pays for Municipal Governments? Pursuing the User Pay Model
Lindsay M. Tedds · In Elsbeth Heaman (Ed.) Who Pays for Canada? Taxes and Fairness · McGill-Queen's University Press · 2020
FACT Canada
📖
Municipal User Fees in Western Canada
Lindsay M. Tedds · In Enid Slack and Richard Bird (Eds.) Financing Municipal Infrastructure: Who Should Pay? · McGill-Queen's University Press · Toronto · 2017
FACT Canada

Journal Article

📰
The Feasibility of Implementing a Congestion Charge on the Halifax Peninsula: Filling the "Missing Link" of Implementation
Catherine Althaus, Lindsay M. Tedds, and Allen McAvoy · Canadian Public Policy · Vol. 37, No. 4, pp. 541–561 · doi:10.3138/cpp.37.4.541 · 2011
Uses the Halifax Peninsula as a case study to expose the technical and administrative challenges of implementing congestion charges — a policy instrument with a well-developed rationale but an underdeveloped implementation literature. Develops eleven ex ante implementation criteria applicable to any congestion charge context, arguing that context-specific political and administrative factors must be recognized alongside economic rationale if implementation is to succeed.
FACT Canada
📰
User Fee Design by Canadian Municipalities: Considerations Arising From Case Law
Kelly Farish and Lindsay M. Tedds · Canadian Tax Journal · Vol. 62, No. 3, pp. 635–670 · 2014
FACT Canada

Task Force Report

🏛️
Report and Recommendations
City of Calgary Financial Task Force · Lindsay M. Tedds, Task Force Member · City of Calgary · 2020
FACT Calgary

Questions about municipal finance or user fee design?

We work with governments and civil society organizations across Canada on evidence-based policy design and evaluation.